Good time for a cap?
Originally posted by lemonlime:
</font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Slayer32:
Just wondering when should you start wondering about getting a cap for the system? Like i said before ive installed a few stereos but in my new car im going a little bit bigger than im used to.
Have a 700wrms 12" sub with a 900wrms mono amp. Using my deck to power 4 speakers in the car also.
Im also planning on getting a matching sub in the future and using 2x 12"...
Any suggestions on a cap?
</font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Slayer32:
Just wondering when should you start wondering about getting a cap for the system? Like i said before ive installed a few stereos but in my new car im going a little bit bigger than im used to.
Have a 700wrms 12" sub with a 900wrms mono amp. Using my deck to power 4 speakers in the car also.
Im also planning on getting a matching sub in the future and using 2x 12"...
Any suggestions on a cap?
Also, what model of amplifier do you have?
It won't hurt to try it out with your stock electical system first. Ensure that you have a healthy battery installed, as that type of power will certainly put a lot of strain on it. Although alternators are not that expensive, labour costs can be expensive [img]graemlins/deal4u.gif[/img] </font>[/QUOTE]
Guest
Posts: n/a
80 amp isn't all that bad really. Many cars come with 100-120 amp factory which is great for anything but a multikilowatt system.
Personally I would look at a good battery: Optima Yellow, Exide Orbital or Canadian Tire Spiral Cell "deep cycle" (rebadged Orbital)
After that depending on what your system is doing for draw I would look at a cap or alt. If you mainly just listen to music everyday then a cap is a good choice. If you want to do SPL comps often then an alternator is the way to go.
Jaydawg knows his stuff - his advice is right on.
Personally I would look at a good battery: Optima Yellow, Exide Orbital or Canadian Tire Spiral Cell "deep cycle" (rebadged Orbital)
After that depending on what your system is doing for draw I would look at a cap or alt. If you mainly just listen to music everyday then a cap is a good choice. If you want to do SPL comps often then an alternator is the way to go.
Jaydawg knows his stuff - his advice is right on.
Unless you run the system a lot with the car off or the alternator is way overtasked, the battery will hardly ever come into play. The alternator is the primary source of current for the car when it is running. Any demand beyond what the alt can supply is handled by the battery. A cap will simply act as a buffer between the two. It will not fix a charging system problem and if your alt is already out of its league with the power you are running (I doubt it with that Sony amp) it would actually become a hinderance.
The only real benefit of the Yellow Top Optima is that it has the current charatceristics of a starting battery (high CCA and lower ESR) and can be deep-cycled and recharged without killing it. If you have a big enough alternator, all the battery will have to do is start the car and its deep-cycle properties won't matter.
The only real benefit of the Yellow Top Optima is that it has the current charatceristics of a starting battery (high CCA and lower ESR) and can be deep-cycled and recharged without killing it. If you have a big enough alternator, all the battery will have to do is start the car and its deep-cycle properties won't matter.
Originally posted by BumpinTalon:
The very last thing you should add to your electrical system is a cap, IMO. Big three -> battery -> alternator, in that order.
The very last thing you should add to your electrical system is a cap, IMO. Big three -> battery -> alternator, in that order.
But I like to proceed in the order of "bang for the buck".
It's not a simple issue of "supply", as so many people confuse it as.
Each of these items plays a role, IMO none should be missing.
Chances are you have a battery, and an alternator, and wiring... including the "big three" (which are present, albeit in stock form).
Chances are you don't have a cap.
Chances are you are putting a more dynamic load on your electrical system than it was designed to handle.
There's two issues:
1) the "supply" aspect - in terms of quantity - how many amperes can the thing supply? It's really a complicated thing to examine, particularly when you dissect all the elements that boil down essentially into the absolute, or average draw that's on your alternator/battery combo.
2) the "dynamic" aspect - which is related to how well your electrical system can respond to dynamic bursts and fast transients.
That's where a capacitor comes into play.
It's not about how much, but how fast.
Consider that any time that you are operating at 14.4v, essentially all current is being drawn from the alternator.
When something (like your amplifier) draws enough current to exceed that which your alternator can provide, the voltage begins to fall.
Once the voltage reaches the level of the battery (12v), the battery can begin supplying current to augment the alternator, to provide that current above and beyond what it's capable of handling. Both are working together - at 12v.
You see your lights dim simply because the voltage level has fallen to 12v, and light bulbs are brighter on 14.4v than they are on 12v.
There's a rise-time though, how long it takes the battery to respond... the transient response of the battery.
A battery charges relatively slowly... and likewise, discharges relatively slowly.
Things get worse when you are talking about deep-cycle batteries (yellow-tops are deep cycle batteries), because the same thicker plates that make them more durable in surviving abuse and deep-discharges, make them slower in transient response - the response time it takes them to "wake up" and begin supplying current.
A capacitor fits in nicely here, because it charges to the highest level of the electrical system - generally 14.4v if wiring is sufficient.
It's noteworthy that it begins discharging as soon as the battery drops below this peak charge level.
Capacitors, in sharp contrast to batteries, have virtually instantanious charge and discharge properties...
...which is why capacitors are shipped with little resistors to charge them initially. Without that, the capacitor would try to suck so much current, so fast, that it could discolor or even weld the ring terminal to the cap.
Similarly, it's capable of discharging it's entire charge in a brief moment.
Even if you upgrade your alternator, large systems can easily exceed 150a, 175a, even 200a... and possibly more current draw at transient peaks in the music.
When this happens...
...what's covering the gap in time in YOUR system, as the alternator voltage is falling, before the battery is able to respond to augment the supply?
Yes, this period in time is only milliseconds in duration... thankfully this is why larger amounts of capacitance aren't necessary in most systems.
But don't discount its value.
Here's a graphic to show the comparison of voltage level, comparing a system reaching a large transient peak, one with a capacitor, one without:
Too many people that misinterpret Richard Clark's capacitor testing that proved that caps don't help amps make more power than they are rated for...


