Rockford Fosgate Punch P2's Or JL Audio W0V2's
 

Both in Ported Boxes, Both 4 Ohm Subs Bridged, JL have 300RMS, Fosgate have 250RMS

Which would you say is a better setup?

Fosgates: http://www.rockfordfosgate.com/products/product_details.asp?cat_id=4&series_id=31&family_i d=10&item_id=108279&locale=en_US&p_status=

JL's : http://mobile.jlaudio.com/products_subs.php?series_id=33

what amp are you using to power them?

i'd say JL cause it costs more, which means its better

More than likely A JL Audio A1400

the thing is with car audio i always thought correct me if i'm wrong that the bigger the size of the magnet the better the sub? The magnet on the W0 is like half the size of the P2

The magnet is only 1 part of the motor structure of the sub......how well the rest of the parts work together to move the cone and radiate heat out of the driver determines the efficiency of the speaker.

If the speakers are rated for such similar amounts of power the larger magnets aren't adding anything........either sub in the correct box with the same power will have very similar output......:smokin:

HTH

Maybe Yuli can answer this...Whatever he says, I would take his advice.